Tote bags and crossbody bags are two of the most popular bag styles, but what's the difference? In this article, we'll break down the key features of each so you can decide which suits you best.
What is a Tote Bag?
A tote bag is an open, large-capacity bag with two parallel handles and no top closure (though some have zips or buttons). They're designed to be carried on your shoulder or in your hand.
Key Features of Tote Bags:
- Roomy and open: Perfect for carrying everything from groceries to books.
- Easy access: No complicated fastenings.
- Stylish options: Available in endless materials, patterns, and sizes.
You can explore our unique handmade tote bag collection to see some great examples.
Pros and Cons of Tote Bags
Pros:
- High capacity
- Versatile for shopping, work, and errands
- Easy to carry
- Eco-friendly options
Cons:
- Less secure (often open top)
- Can get heavy if overfilled
- No compartments for organisation
What is a Crossbody Bag?
A crossbody bag is a smaller, more compact bag worn diagonally across your body with a long strap.
Key Features of Crossbody Bags:
- Hands-free convenience: Keeps your essentials close without using your hands.
- Security: Worn across the body, making it harder to lose or misplace.
- Compact size: Ideal for carrying just the essentials.
You can browse our handmade crossbody bag collection to see practical, stylish options.
Pros and Cons of Crossbody Bags
Pros:
- Secure and close to the body
- Lightweight and compact
- Leaves your hands free
- Stylish and easy to wear
Cons:
- Limited capacity
- Not ideal for carrying larger items
Tote Bags vs Crossbody Bag: What's the Difference?
Here’s a simple comparison table to help you decide:
| Feature | Tote Bag | Crossbody Bag |
|---|---|---|
| Size | Large, open, often unstructured | Small to medium, compact |
| How you wear it | Over the shoulder or handheld | Across the body |
| Best for | Shopping, day trips, work, errands | Commuting, travel, events |
| Capacity | High | Low to medium |
| Security | Open top, less secure | Zipped, close to the body |
| Style vibe | Casual, functional, stylish | Minimal, sleek, hands-free |
Real-World Example: When I Use Each Bag
For me, a tote bag is my go-to when I’m out for a full day — whether I’m teaching, running errands, or heading to a market. I can throw in my notebook, a water bottle, and even a few groceries on the way home.
A crossbody bag, on the other hand, is what I grab when I’m popping out to meet a friend, heading to a fair, or walking the dog. I don’t want to carry much, just my phone, keys, and wallet — and I like having my hands free.
Common Mistakes People Make When Choosing Between the Two
- Choosing style over function: Some people buy a crossbody bag thinking it will hold everything their tote does — and end up frustrated.
- Underestimating size needs: A crossbody is perfect for essentials, but if you’re a 'carry everything' person, it won’t be big enough.
- Ignoring comfort: Tote bags can become heavy; crossbody bags can dig into your shoulder if overfilled.
- Thinking one bag does it all: Many people benefit from having both — one for everyday errands and one for lighter, hands-free days.
When Should You Choose a Tote Bag?
Choose a tote bag if you:
- Need to carry larger items or multiple things.
- Want an easy, grab-and-go solution.
- Prefer a casual, spacious bag.
- Like versatility — tote bags are suitable for shopping, the beach, or even work.
For more on why tote bags are so popular, check out our post on the benefits of tote bags vs plastic bags.
When Should You Choose a Crossbody Bag?
A crossbody bag is best when you:
- Want to keep your hands free.
- Need to carry only essentials (phone, wallet, keys).
- Prioritise security and easy movement.
- Prefer a sleek, stylish accessory for events or daily errands.
FAQs: Tote Bags vs Crossbody Bag
Which is better: tote bag or crossbody bag?
It depends on your needs. Tote bags are ideal for carrying larger items, while crossbody bags are great for hands-free convenience and carrying essentials securely.
Are tote bags more eco-friendly?
Tote bags can be more eco-friendly, especially when made from sustainable materials. They’re reusable and reduce the need for single-use plastic bags.
Are crossbody bags more secure?
Yes. Crossbody bags sit close to your body and often have zip closures, making them harder to lose or steal.
Can I use both?
Absolutely! Many people use tote bags for shopping or work and crossbody bags for quick errands or travel. They serve different purposes.
Final Thoughts: Tote Bags vs Crossbody Bag
Both tote bags and crossbody bags have their place. Tote bags win on space and versatility, while crossbody bags offer security and hands-free practicality. Choosing the right one depends on how you plan to use it.
Want to see both in action? Browse our handmade tote bag collection and handmade crossbody bag collection and pick the one that works for your lifestyle.
