Two people holding a colorful tote bag and a classic shoulder bag, showing the contrast between the two bag styles in a city setting.

Tote Bag vs Shoulder Bags: What's the Difference?

Are tote bags better than shoulder bags? It’s a question many people face when choosing the right everyday bag. Today, I’ll settle it — quickly and clearly.

In this guide, you’ll learn the key differences between tote bags and shoulder bags, so you can decide which one fits your lifestyle best.

What is a Tote Bag?

A tote bag is typically larger and open at the top. It’s made to carry more items, making it great for shopping, work, or everyday use. Tote bags are often crafted from durable materials like canvas or leather, making them sturdy and practical.

Tote bag and shoulder bag side by side, showcasing the size and design differences in a casual setting

What is a Shoulder Bag?

A shoulder bag is smaller and more compact, often designed for daily outings and more formal settings. It typically features a single strap that rests over the shoulder, offering a sleek, hands-free option. Shoulder bags often come with zippers and compartments to keep your items organised.

Tote Bag vs Shoulder Bags: Key Differences

Feature Tote Bag Shoulder Bag
Size Larger, roomier Smaller, more compact
Strap Two parallel handles Single strap for over-the-shoulder use
Style Casual, functional Versatile, can be casual or formal
Best For Work, shopping, gym Casual outings, day trips, evenings
Organisation One large compartment Multiple compartments and zips

Two women sitting at a café, smiling and holding coffee cups, each with a different style of bag — a shoulder bag and a tote bag — showing the variety in bag styles.

Pros and Cons of Tote Bags

Pros:

  • Great for carrying multiple items
  • Easy access due to open-top design
  • Versatile for various occasions like work, shopping, or travel

Cons:

  • Can become heavy if overpacked
  • Lack of internal organisation for smaller items

Pros and Cons of Shoulder Bags

Pros:

  • Compact and stylish, great for everyday use
  • Often comes with organised compartments
  • Suitable for both casual and formal occasions

Cons:

  • Limited space compared to totes
  • Can be uncomfortable if packed with too many items

Real-World Example: When to Choose Each Bag

Imagine you're heading to work. You’ve got a laptop, notebook, and lunch — a tote bag is perfect for holding everything you need. But if you're heading out for a dinner date or a quick coffee with friends, a shoulder bag offers a more stylish and compact option for essentials like your phone, keys, and wallet.

When you're deciding between a tote bag and a shoulder bag, the tote bag wins for versatility and space. You can easily carry everything from a laptop to groceries in one. If you're looking for something more compact, though, a crossbody bag or shoulder bag might be a better fit. Shoulder bags, especially, are great for carrying just the essentials, with some offering added organisation through compartments. You can explore our Tote Bag Collection for a variety of spacious, practical options. Alternatively, if you prefer a more sleek, organised choice, take a look at our Crossbody Bags Collection.

So, Are Tote Bags Better Than Shoulder Bags?

The answer depends on your lifestyle and needs:

  • If you need more space and versatility, a tote bag is the way to go.
  • If you prefer a smaller, more organised option, a shoulder bag is the better choice.

In short: Tote bags are great for function and space. Shoulder bags excel in style, compactness, and organisation.

Find Your Perfect Bag

If you’re ready to choose the perfect bag for your lifestyle, check out our Tote Bag Collection or explore our Crossbody Bags Collection to find the best match for your needs.

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.

  • A small dog sits on a kitchen table beside a steaming mug with a spoon inside, a colourful tea towel, and a few slices of toast. The dog stares directly at the camera, giving the scene a cosy but slightly chaotic morning vibe.

    Signs of Creative Burnout (That Don’t Look Like...

    Debbie Palmer

    Wondering if you're tired or quietly combusting? This honest (and funny) guide walks through the real signs of creative burnout — and what to do when it hits.

    Signs of Creative Burnout (That Don’t Look Like...

    Debbie Palmer

    Wondering if you're tired or quietly combusting? This honest (and funny) guide walks through the real signs of creative burnout — and what to do when it hits.

  • Woman in her 50s walking through a busy UK market with a crossbody bag, hands free, holding a reusable coffee cup

    Why Are Crossbody Bags So Popular?

    Debbie Palmer

    Why are crossbody bags so popular? It’s not just a fashion trend — they’re comfortable, secure, and incredibly versatile. Here’s why more and more people are switching to crossbody bags.

    Why Are Crossbody Bags So Popular?

    Debbie Palmer

    Why are crossbody bags so popular? It’s not just a fashion trend — they’re comfortable, secure, and incredibly versatile. Here’s why more and more people are switching to crossbody bags.

  • A smiling woman with a canvas tote bag unloads groceries from the back of a car while her two young children help. The scene takes place on a residential street, suggesting a practical, everyday use for the bag.

    Which Type of Bag Is Best for Everyday Use?

    Debbie Palmer

    Not sure which type of bag works best for daily life? This guide compares comfort, practicality, and material choices to help you find the perfect bag for everyday use.

    Which Type of Bag Is Best for Everyday Use?

    Debbie Palmer

    Not sure which type of bag works best for daily life? This guide compares comfort, practicality, and material choices to help you find the perfect bag for everyday use.

1 of 3